Thanks William, that sounds like a plan. Although the site is old and I'd prefer a fresh install to remove any potential issues. So I tried my way and it worked - kind of ;)
On the front end for k2 items I get
but the database structure must be the same because k2 is working fine in the backend, so now I have all the content and categories in k2 2.5
I haven't imported all the old users into the new install, so will need to change the author for all 90 pages. Could it be something to do with that?