If the category is inheriting its settings from another category then the master category's settings will be respected instead.
Furthermore if you are using a multi-category menu item, the setting will be located in the menu item's params.
If both of these do not work, then you need to ask the template's developers if they use a framework which alters Joomla!'s default overriding method.
JoomlaWorks Support Team
---
Please search the forum before posting a new topic :)